Skip to main content
Pies on 37

Pies on 37

1311 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08755
732-538-8869

Order Ahead We open at 11:00 AM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    deals-and-coupons

    Deals and Coupons

    Deal

    Large Plain Pie With Soda

    $19.99

    Deal

    Large Grandma Pie

    $3 off grandma pie.

    $20.45

    pizza

    Pizza

    Best seller

    Plain Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $15.45

    Best seller

    Sicilian Pizza

    $21.00

    Best seller

    White Pizza

    $15.50

    Sicilian Pizza Bread

    Our Sicilian pizza topped with our special sauce, light garlic and parmesan cheese, perfect for a party appetizer.

    $23.00

    Bar Pie

    $16.45

    Gluten Free Pizza

    $14.95

    Grandma Pizza

    Thin, square crust with fresh mozzarella, basil & red sauce.

    $23.45

    Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pan Cheese Pizza

    $13.95

    gourmet-pizza

    Gourmet Pizza

    Chicken Vodka Sauce Pizza

    $23.50

    Five Cheese Pizza

    $22.50

    Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

    $23.50

    Margherita Pizza

    $23.50

    Chicken Francese Pizza

    $23.50

    Meatlovers Pizza

    $23.50

    Chicken Marsala Pizza

    $23.50

    Mac & Cheese Pizza

    $25.00

    Shrimp Scampi Pizza

    $25.95

    Bacon Mac & Cheese Pizza

    $26.00

    Special Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers.

    $23.95

    Balsamic Chicken Pizza

    $25.00

    Cheesesteak Pizza

    Peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

    $23.95

    Penne Vodka Pizza

    $23.50

    Hot Honey Margherita Pizza

    Fresh mozzarella, basil, pepperoni cups and hot honey.

    $25.95

    Baked Ziti Pizza

    $23.50

    Veggie Pizza

    Onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli.

    $23.50

    Chipotle Chicken Cheesesteak Pizza

    $24.50

    Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizza

    $23.50

    Pickle Pizza

    $22.00

    Chicken Wing Pizza

    Choose buffalo, honey BBQ, sweet chili, boom boom or garlic parmesan.

    $23.50

    Hawaiian Pizza

    $23.00

    Sicilian Special Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers.

    $25.95

    Burrata Margherita Pizza

    The queen of cheese over our delicious sauce topped with arugula and balsamic drizzle.

    $30.00

    Chicken Murphy Pizza

    Peppers, onions, hot peppers and potatoes.

    $24.50

    Big Mac Pizza

    Ground beef topped with cheese, lettuce, pickles, onions and our special sauce.

    $30.00

    appetizers

    Appetizers

    Cheese Balls

    $9.95

    Scampi Mussels

    $15.95

    Jalapeno Poppers

    $8.95

    Fried Calamari

    $15.95

    Onion Rings

    $7.95

    Best seller

    Fries

    $6.95

    Fried Mushrooms

    Served with red sauce, ranch, or horseradish.

    $9.95

    Cheese Fries

    $8.45

    Zucchini Sticks

    Served with ranch.

    $9.95

    Garlic Knots

    $4.95

    Sweet Potato Fries

    $7.50

    Eggplant Rollatini

    $9.95

    Meatballs

    $9.95

    Chicken Fingers

    With fries.

    $12.99

    Sausage

    $9.95

    Garlic Bread

    $4.95

    Hot Mussels

    $15.95

    Garlic Bread with Cheese

    $5.95

    Sweet Mussels

    $15.95

    Mozzarella Caprese

    Fresh mozzarella, Jersey tomatoes, roasted peppers, balsamic glaze, and fresh basil.

    $14.95

    Mild Mussels

    $15.95

    Best seller

    Mozzarella Sticks

    $8.50

    salads

    Salads

    Antipasto Salad

    Iceberg lettuce, roasted peppers, cucumber, black and green olives, red onion, tomato, ham, salami, provolone, fresh mozzarella.

    $14.95

    Paisano Salad

    Romaine, grilled chicken, roasted peppers, cucumber, olives, red onion, artichoke heart, bacon, fresh mozzarella, house vinaigrette.

    $14.95

    Chef Salad

    Roast beef, turkey, provolone, iceberg lettuce, red onion, cucumber, tomato, black and green olives.

    $14.95

    Autumn Salad

    Romaine, grilled chicken, walnuts, craisins, red onion, feta cheese.

    $14.95

    Garden Salad

    Iceberg lettuce, cucumber, black and green olives, tomato, red onion.

    $11.00

    California Chicken Salad

    Iceberg lettuce, breaded chicken, tomato, red onion, cucumber, olives.

    $14.95

    Calista Salad

    Romaine, eggplant, prosciutto, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, provolone, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, cucumber, olives & red onion.

    $16.00

    Caesar Salad

    $12.95

    Buffalo Bleu Salad

    Iceberg and Romaine mix; buffalo grilled chicken, grape tomato, cucumber and chunky bleu cheese dressing.

    $14.95

    Boom Boom Shrimp Salad

    Jumbo shrimp tossed in boom boom sauce & served over romaine with cherry tomatoes, bacon, fresh mozzarella, cucumber & red onion.

    $16.50

    Greek Salad

    Romaine, gaeta olives, feta cheese, grape tomato, red onion.

    $11.00

    wings

    Wings

    Regular Wings

    Served with sauce on the side or dipped in sauce.

    $9.95

    Boneless Wings

    Served with blue cheese or ranch.

    $7.95

    calzones

    Calzones

    Cheesesteak Calzone

    Peppers, onions, mushrooms.

    $14.00

    Ham Calzone

    $13.50

    Veggie Calzone

    Peppers, onions, mushrooms, broccoli.

    $13.50

    Cheese Calzone

    Mozzarella and ricotta.

    $12.50

    strombolis

    Strombolis

    Pepperoni & Cheese Stromboli

    $12.50

    Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Pepperoni & Mozzarella Stromboli

    $13.50

    Cheesesteak Stromboli

    Peppers, onions, mushrooms.

    $13.50

    Vegetarian Stromboli

    Peppers, onions, mushrooms, broccoli.

    $13.50

    Chicken Parmigiana Stromboli

    $13.50

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli

    $13.50

    cold-subs

    Cold Subs

    All Cold Subs are served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil & vinegar. Chipotle Sauce or Horseradish available on request. Cold Subs are sliced fresh and made to order.

    Ham, Provolone & Salami Sub

    $10.50

    Roast Beef Sub

    $12.95

    Ham, Provolone & Capicola Sub

    $10.50

    Turkey Sub

    $11.95

    Ham, Provolone, Salami & Capicola Sub

    $10.95

    Roast Beef & Turkey Sub

    $11.95

    BLT Sub

    $10.50

    Tuna Sub

    $10.50

    hot-subs

    Hot Subs

    Chicken Parmigiana Sub

    $10.50

    Chicken Vodka Parmigiana Sub

    $10.50

    Veal Parmigiana Sub

    $10.50

    Italian Hot Dog

    $10.50

    Shrimp Parmigiana Sub

    $10.50

    Pepper & Egg Sub

    $10.50

    Sausage Parmigiana Sub

    $10.50

    California Chicken Sandwich

    Breaded chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion,and mayo.

    $10.50

    Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

    $10.50

    Sausage & Peppers Sub

    With onion and marinara.

    $10.50

    Meatball Parmigiana Sub

    $10.50

    Italiano Sub

    Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic glaze.

    $10.50

    paninis

    Paninis

    All served with fries & a pickle.

    Buffalo Chicken Panini

    Grilled or breaded buffalo chicken, provolone, bleu cheese.

    $13.50

    New Yorker Panini

    Roast beef, Swiss, sautéed onion, deli mustard.

    $14.95

    Caprese Panini

    Fresh mozzarella, Jersey tomatoes, pesto spread, balsamic glaze.

    $14.95

    Godfather Panini

    Prosciutto, roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella topped with balsamic glaze.

    $14.95

    Chicken Parmesan Panini

    Tomato sauce or vodka sauce.

    $13.95

    Ella Panini

    Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, pesto spread, balsamic glaze.

    $14.95

    Siciliano Panini

    Eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze.

    $14.95

    Spinach & Artichoke Panini

    Sautéed spinach, artichoke, fresh mozzarella and garlic parmesan sauce.

    $14.95

    Chipotle Chicken Panini

    Grilled chicken, American cheese, lettuce, tomato with chipotle sauce.

    $13.95

    wraps

    Wraps

    Whole wheat, white wrap, or gluten-free wrap. Served with fries or a side salad.

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

    Fried chicken, bacon, ranch, lettuce, tomato.

    $14.95

    Italiano Wrap

    Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze.

    $13.95

    Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    Grilled or breaded chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, provolone, bleu cheese.

    $14.95

    Greek Wrap

    Romaine lettuce, grape tomato, gaeta olives, feta cheese, balsamic glaze, mushrooms.

    $12.95

    Chicken Caesar Wrap

    Grilled chicken, crisp romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing.

    $13.95

    Veggie Wrap

    Eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms.

    $12.95

    Ranchero Wrap

    Fried chicken, bacon, american, provolone, ranch dressing.

    $14.95

    Turkey BLT Wrap

    Thinly sliced turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayo, american cheese.

    $14.95

    cheesesteaks

    Cheesesteaks

    All cheesesteaks come with American cheese.

    Plain Cheesesteak

    Cheese sauce is available upon request.

    $10.50

    Pizza Steak

    With sauce and mozzarella.

    $12.50

    Special Cheesesteak

    Peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

    $11.50

    Chicken Cheesesteak

    $11.50

    Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

    With American cheese and buffalo sauce.

    $11.50

    Chipotle Chicken Cheesesteak

    $11.50

    California Cheesesteak

    Lettuce, tomato, onions and mayo.

    $11.50

    pasta

    Pasta

    Choose your pasta: ziti • spaghetti • linguine • capellini & match it with your choice of sauce. Gluten-free pasta is available.

    Pasta with Tomato Sauce

    $14.00

    Pasta with Butter & Garlic

    $14.50

    Pasta with Marinara Sauce

    $14.00

    Pasta with Meat Sauce

    $16.50

    Pasta with Meatballs

    $15.00

    Pasta with Vodka Sauce

    $16.50

    Pasta with Sausage

    $15.00

    Pasta with Red Clam Sauce

    $17.50

    Pasta with Garlic & Oil

    $14.50

    Pasta with White Clam Sauce

    $17.50

    specialty-pasta

    Specialty Pasta

    All specialty pastas are served with a salad & bread. Gluten-Free Pasta Available.

    Stuffed Rigatoni Vodka

    $19.00

    Fettuccine Alfredo With Grilled Chicken

    $20.95

    Cavatelli & Broccoli

    $17.00

    Fettuccine Alfredo With Grilled Shrimp

    $22.95

    Stuffed Shells

    $16.50

    Eggplant Parmigiana Pasta

    $18.95

    Penne Puttanesca

    Marinara, capers, and black olives.

    $17.95

    Eggplant Rollatini Pasta

    $19.95

    Pasta Primavera

    Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic.

    $17.95

    Cheese Ravioli

    $16.50

    Pasta Primavera with Grilled Chicken

    Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic.

    $20.95

    Cheese Tortellini

    Alfredo or vodka sauce.

    $18.00

    Pasta Primavera with Grilled Shrimp

    Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic.

    $22.95

    Tortellini Carbonara

    Alfredo sauce, prosciutto and peas.

    $19.95

    Baked Ziti

    $16.50

    Stuffed Rigatoni Sebastian

    Topped with vodka sauce, melted mozzarella, and breaded chicken.

    $21.95

    Baked Ziti Sicilian-Style

    With chopped eggplant.

    $17.50

    Lasagna

    Homemade meat lasagna topped with melted mozzarella & tomato sauce.

    $16.95

    Fettuccine Alfredo

    $17.95

    entrees

    Entrees

    All entrees include pasta, salad & bread. Our chicken is all natural & certified organic. Never been given antibiotics, vegetarian diet fed & has no added growth hormones.Gluten-Free Pasta Available.

    Chicken Alla Prosciutto

    Chicken sautéed with butter & wine topped with prosciutto & mozzarella on a bed of spinach.

    $20.99

    Chicken Cacciatore

    Tender pieces of chicken, mixed peppers, onions & mushrooms in marinara sauce.

    $20.99

    Chicken Parmesan

    Chicken breast seasoned & baked under a layer of blended Italian cheese.

    $20.99

    Chicken Marsala

    Chicken breast sautéed in a light Marsala wine, accompanied by fresh mushrooms.

    $20.99

    Veal Parmesan

    Veal seasoned & baked under a layer of blended Italian cheese.

    $21.99

    Chicken Garden

    Chicken with broccoli, mushrooms & tomatoes in a garlic wine sauce.

    $20.99

    Chicken Piccata

    Chicken breast sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce with mushrooms and capers.

    $20.99

    Chicken Scarpariella

    Chicken & sausage combined with mushrooms, onions & wine in a pink sauce.

    $20.99

    Chicken Caprese

    Breaded cutlet topped with ricotta cheese, eggplant, mozzarella & tomato sauce.

    $20.99

    Chicken Pisano

    Chicken breast, eggplant, mushrooms & roasted red peppers in a cream wine sauce.

    $20.99

    Chicken Francese

    Tender chicken breast battered in eggs & sautéed in our white wine & lemon sauce.

    $20.99

    Grilled Chicken Dinner

    Served with sautéed broccoli.

    $20.99

    Chicken Murphy

    Chicken breast, potatoes, onions & hot peppers in a white wine sauce.

    $20.99

    seafood

    Seafood

    All entrees include pasta, salad & bread. Gluten-Free Pasta Available.

    Mussels Marinara

    Chicken sautéed with butter & wine topped with prosciutto & mozzarella on a bed of spinach.

    $21.99

    Fried Shrimp

    $21.99

    Shrimp Vodka Sauce

    Over pasta.

    $21.99

    Shrimp Scampi

    Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a wine, butter & garlic sauce with fresh lemon.

    $21.99

    Shrimp Parmigiana

    Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a sauce, covered in mozzarella & baked.

    $21.99

    Shrimp Marinara

    Sautéed with garlic & wine in our marinara.

    $21.99

    Grilled Shrimp Dinner

    Served with sautéed broccoli.

    $21.99

    Shrimp Fra Diavolo

    Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a garlic wine & spicy marinara sauce.

    $21.99

    Calamari Alla Marinara

    Sautéed in wine, garlic & our own marinara.

    $21.99

    Shrimp Garden

    Shrimp with broccoli, mushrooms & tomatoes in a garlic wine sauce.

    $21.99

    Pies on 37 - View Menu & Order Online - 1311 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08755 - Slice

    SliceNJToms River08755 Pies on 37
    Price: $$