Skip to main content
Coney Island Pizza, Wings & Hot Dogs

Coney Island Pizza, Wings & Hot Dogs

171 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940
845-493-2175
New

Order Ahead We open at Sat at 11:30 AM

Full Hours
    NY Health ScoreNew window icon
    Skip to first category
    starters

    Starters

    Nachos

    Cheddar or salsa.

    $9.00

    Tater Tots

    Try cheesy or loaded!

    $8.00

    Deluxe Nachos with Beef

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, jalapeños, black beans (sour cream & salsa on the side).

    $15.00

    Mozzarella Stix

    $9.00

    Deluxe Nachos with Chicken

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, jalapeños, black beans (sour cream & salsa on the side).

    $15.00

    Cheese Quesadilla

    $11.00

    Twin Tacos

    Lettuce, tomatoes and cheddar Jack cheese.

    $11.00

    Beef Quesadilla

    $14.00

    Double Decker Twin Tacos

    Combined hard and soft taco shells with lettuce, tomatoes & cheddar Jack cheese

    $12.00

    Chicken Quesadilla

    $14.00

    Natural Cut Fries

    Try cheesy or loaded!

    $7.50

    Onion Rings

    $6.85

    Curly Fries

    Try cheesy or loaded!

    $7.50

    Garlic Knots

    $3.40

    hot-dogs

    Hot Dogs

    Coney Island Hot Dogs
    Best seller

    Coney Island Chili Dog

    Our chili sauce, mustard, diced onion

    $3.49

    Plain Dog

    $2.99

    Mexican

    Mustard, mayo, ketchup, tomato, grilled onions, jalapeños, bacon

    $4.99

    Build your own Hot Dog

    $2.99

    New Yorker

    Spicy mustard, grilled onions, sauerkraut

    $4.99

    Philly

    Grilled Onions, Cheddar Cheese

    $4.99

    Chicago

    Mustard, onions, relish, pickle, tomato, jalapeños

    $4.99

    Red Onion Sauce Dog

    $4.99

    Manhattan

    Red Onion Sauce, Mustard, Sauerkraut.

    $4.99

    Southwestern

    Coney Island chili sauce, cheese, jalapeño, ketchup

    $4.99

    slice

    Slice

    Plain Pizza Slice

    A slice of pizza with a base of tomato sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese, served on a traditional crust.

    $3.00

    BBQ Pizza Slice

    A slice of pizza topped with barbecue sauce, chicken, and a blend of cheeses, typically finished with a drizzle of additional barbecue sauce.

    $4.00

    Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    A slice of pizza topped with spicy pepperoni and a blend of melted cheeses on a classic crust.

    $3.50

    Chicken Parm Pizza Slice

    Breaded chicken topped with marinara sauce and melted parmesan cheese, served on a crispy pizza slice.

    $3.50

    Sausage Pizza Slice

    Sausage slice typically consists of a portion of sausage, cut into thin slices, often enjoyed for its seasoned and savory taste.

    $3.50

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice

    A pizza slice topped with seasoned chicken, crispy bacon, and a drizzle of creamy ranch dressing on a classic crust.

    $3.50

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice

    Sliced pizza topped with buffalo sauce, chicken, and a blend of cheeses, often accompanied by a drizzle of ranch or blue cheese dressing.

    $4.00

    Coney Island Slice

    A slice of pizza with a base of our signature Coney Island chili sauce and topped with cheddar cheese & onions, served on a traditional crust.

    $4.00

    wings-original

    Wings – Original

    Includes extra celery & blue cheese.
    Best seller

    Original Wings

    $8.50

    wings-boneless

    Wings – Boneless

    Includes extra celery & blue cheese.
    Best seller

    Boneless Wings

    $8.50

    pizza

    Pizza

    Cheese Pizza

    A medium-sized pizza featuring a blend of cheeses over a classic tomato sauce, served on a traditional crust.

    $16.00

    Supreme Veggie Pizza

    Tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese topped with onions, peppers and mushrooms.

    $18.00

    Meatlovers Pizza

    Tomato sauce, pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, ground beef, meatballs and mozzarella cheese.

    $20.00

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    Bacon, chicken, mozzarella with ranch dressing.

    $18.00

    Hawaiian Pizza

    Tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham & pineapple.

    $18.00

    White Pizza

    $19.40

    Chicken Parm Pizza

    Tomato sauce, chopped breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella & grated cheese.

    $18.00

    Coney Island Pie

    A slice of pizza with a base of our signature chili sauce and topped with cheddar cheese & onions, served on a traditional crust.

    $21.00

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Mozzarella cheese, chopped breaded chicken cutlet topped with hot sauce.

    $18.00

    salads

    Salads

    Mixed Garden Salad

    Mixed spring greens and romaine topped with tomatoes, cucumbers and home-style croutons. Choice of Italian or ranch dressing.

    $12.00

    Chicken BLT Salad

    Fresh grilled chicken breast, crispy bacon and tomatoes, topped with fresh avocado and home-style croutons on a bed of spring greens and romaine. Choice of Italian or ranch dressing.

    $16.00

    Chicken Caesar Salad

    Grilled or crispy fresh chicken. Served on a bed of greens and romaine with home-style croutons and our creamy Caesar dressing.

    $15.00

    Taco Salad

    Mexican style fresh grilled chicken, homemade pico de gallo and avocado on a field of greens, topped with tortilla chips and served with sour cream.

    $16.00

    Thai Chicken Salad

    Fresh grilled chicken breast, crushed peanuts, shredded cabbage, and wonton noodles on a bed of spring greens and romaine with sesame ginger soy dressing.

    $16.00

    Buffalo Salad

    Grilled or crispy fresh chicken tossed in our wing sauce. Served on a bed of greens and romaine with tomatoes, chopped celery, home-style croutons and our chunky blue cheese dressing.

    $16.00

    calzones-rolls-heroes

    Calzones, Rolls & Heroes

    Cheese Calzone

    Personal or family size.

    $10.25

    Chicken Parm Hero

    $10.85

    Pepperoni Roll

    Personal or family size

    $10.25

    Sausage & Pepper Parm Hero

    $10.85

    Chicken Roll

    Personal or family size

    $10.25

    Baked Ziti

    $10.25

    Stromboli

    Small or large

    $10.25

    Baked Ziti with Garlic Knots

    $14.80

    Meatball Parm Hero

    $9.70

    tenders

    Tenders

    Tenders

    $10.00

    burgers

    Burgers

    Best seller

    Boardwalk Burger

    Roasted jalapeño, jack cheddar, braised onions, lettuce and chipotle mayo.

    $15.00

    Original Burger

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles & mayo

    $12.00

    BBQ Bacon & Cheddar Burger

    Roasted jalapeño, jack cheddar, braised onions, lettuce & chipotle mayo

    $15.00

    sandwiches

    Sandwiches

    Best seller

    Loaded Cheesesteak Sandwich

    Thin sliced rib steak with your choice of cheese with grilled onions and grilled peppers.

    $16.00

    Original Cheesesteak Sandwich

    Thin sliced rib steak with your choice of cheese.

    $13.00

    Classic Chicken Sandwich

    Served on your choice of ciabatta, pita, or wrap.

    $13.00

    Chipotle Cheesesteak Sandwich

    Thin sliced rib steak with cheese, bacon, grilled onions and our chipotle mayo sauce.

    $16.00

    Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

    Served on your choice of ciabatta, pita, or wrap. Served with medium buffalo sauce (no substitutions.

    $16.00

    Chipotle Chicken Sandwich

    Served on your choice of ciabatta, pita, or wrap. Served with chipotle mayo.

    $16.00

    Beef Gyro

    Beef, lettuce, tomato, onion and tzatziki sauce.

    $14.00

    Hot Honey Cheesesteak Sandwich

    $13.70

    Chicken Gyro

    Chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion and tzatziki sauce.

    $14.00

    cookies

    Cookies

    Oatmeal Raisin

    $3.00

    Peanut Butter with Reese's

    $3.00

    Triple Chocolate

    $3.00

    beverages

    Beverages

    Soda

    $1.49

    Fruit Punch

    $1.49

    Sunkist Orange

    $1.49

    kids

    Kids

    Kid's Wings

    Fries and drink.

    $15.00

    Kid's Dino Nuggets

    Fries and drink.

    $12.00

    Coney Island Pizza, Wings & Hot Dogs - View Menu & Order Online - 171 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940 - Slice

    Price: $$