Skip to main content
The Pie Guy

The Pie Guy

83 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013
646-895-9507

Open until 3:00 AM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category

    House Favorites

    These are the shop recommendations for a great meal experience.

    The Classic Pizza

    Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.

    Meat Lovers Pizza Slice

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled Italian sausage, and bacon.

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    Margherita Pizza

    Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, a touch of Tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.

    Classic White Pie Pizza

    Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.

    picked-for-you

    Picked for You

    The Classic Pizza

    Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.

    $29.00

    The Classic Pizza

    Meat Lovers Pizza Slice

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled Italian sausage, and bacon.

    $6.00

    Meat Lovers Pizza Slice

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    $36.00

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    Italian Sausage Pizza

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with crumbled Italian style sausage.

    $35.00

    Italian Sausage Pizza
    menu-for-pizza-guy

    Menu for Pizza Guy

    Classic White Pie Pizza

    Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.

    $34.00

    Classic White Pie Pizza

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    $36.00

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    Margherita Pizza

    Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, a touch of Tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.

    $35.00

    Margherita Pizza

    The Classic Pizza

    Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.

    $29.00

    The Classic Pizza

    Mushroom Pizza

    Classic NY-style pizza with mushroom topping.

    $34.00

    Mushroom Pizza

    Grandma Pizza

    Homemade mozzarella, crushed tomatoes, basil, fresh garlic, authentic pecorino romano, and extra virgin olive oil.

    $38.00

    Italian Sausage Pizza

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with crumbled Italian style sausage.

    $35.00

    Italian Sausage Pizza

    Meat Lovers Pizza

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled Italian sausage, and bacon.

    $36.00

    Meat Lovers Pizza

    Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza

    Our delicious homemade vodka sauce is finished with Calabrian chili, fresh mozzarella, and baked rigatoni.

    $39.00

    Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza
    Best seller

    Pepperoni Pizza

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with spicy pepperoni.

    $34.00

    Pepperoni Pizza

    Vodka Sauce Pizza

    Our delicious homemade light red cream sauce with sauteed prosciutto di parma and vodka with fresh mozzarella.

    $32.00

    Vodka Sauce Pizza

    Supreme Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms

    $38.00

    slices

    Slices

    The Classic Pizza Slice

    Classic New York pizza style with whole milk mozzarella and our classic tomato-basil sauce.

    $5.50

    The Classic Pizza Slice
    Best seller

    Margherita Pizza Slice

    Homemade mozzarella and chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs, a touch of Tuscan olive oil finished with fresh basil.

    $5.50

    Margherita Pizza Slice
    Best seller

    Meat Lovers Pizza Slice

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with our spicy pepperoni, crumbled Italian sausage, and bacon.

    $6.00

    Meat Lovers Pizza Slice

    Classic White Pizza Slice

    Extra mozzarella cheese topped with whole milk ricotta, hints of caramelized onions, finished with pecorino romano cheese.

    $6.25

    Classic White Pizza Slice

    Vodka Sauce Pizza Slice

    Our delicious homemade light red cream sauce with sauteed prosciutto di parma and vodka with fresh mozzarella.

    $5.25

    Vodka Sauce Pizza Slice

    Mushroom Pizza Slice

    Classic NY-style pizza with mushroom topping.

    $5.25

    Mushroom Pizza Slice
    Best seller

    Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    Classic NY-style pizza topped with spicy pepperoni.

    $5.50

    Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    Supreme Pizza Slice

    Pepperoni, sausage peppers, onions, mushrooms

    $6.50

    Best seller

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice

    $6.50

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice
    rolls-and-knots

    Rolls and Knots

    Pepperoni Roll

    $14.00

    drinks

    Drinks

    Bottle of water

    $2.00

    Ginger Ale

    $2.00

    Coke

    $2.00

    Sprite

    $2.00

    Diet Coke

    $2.00

    Pepsi

    $2.00

    Ratings & Reviews
    4.2
    8 ratings

    The Pie Guy - View Menu & Order Online - 83 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013 - Slice

    SliceNYNew York10013 The Pie Guy
    Price: $$